Skip to content
Plug & Prep

Hub 04 · Baking Gear · Baking Gear

The best cookie cutters

Two different purchases hide behind one phrase. A graduated set of stainless rounds is a precision tool you use for biscuits, scones and tarts all year; a set of holiday shapes comes out once. Buy the first one first.

By Stephen V.Updated How we pick
#ad

We earn a commission when you buy through our Amazon links, at no extra cost to you. It never changes our rankings, and we say so when the cheaper product is the better buy. How this works.

Buy the Ateco 5457 Plain Edge Round Cutters, 12-Piece. Retailers publish it as twelve graduated stainless rounds from roughly 7/8 inch to about 4 3/8 inch, 1 1/4 inch tall, nesting into one storage tin — and that is a tool you will use most weeks of the year rather than one week in December. Biscuits, scones, doughnuts, English muffins, dumpling wrappers, tart bases and plain sugar cookies are all round. If you want letters and numbers, nothing metal provides them and the Wilton 101-piece does; buy it knowing Wilton's own catalog lists that set as plastic, which the Amazon listing title does not mention. The Ateco 5307 fluted set is the crimped edge for scones and jam tarts. The Wilton snowflake 7-piece is the one holiday set we would actually buy, because it is seven sizes of one shape rather than one of seven shapes. And the Fox Run stainless star set is five graduated stars for pocket money.

The criteria: metal first, depth second, shapes last

A cutter is a shaped rim you press through dough. There is less to it than almost anything else in a kitchen, which is exactly why the few specs that exist decide everything.

1. What the metal is. This is the spec, and it is usually the one not published. Stainless steel can be left wet in a sink, washed hot, and pressed back into shape. Tinplate— steel with a thin tin coating, which is what most inexpensive novelty cutters are — rusts the moment the coating is scratched or the cutter is put away damp, and that rust is on the surface that touches food. Aluminumis soft and goes permanently oval. Plastic cannot be sharpened, cannot be re-rounded, and does not cut chilled stiff dough cleanly. Both Ateco sets here publish stainless and so does Fox Run; the Wilton snowflake set publishes “metal” with no grade, and the Wilton 101-piece is plastic.

2. Cutting depth. The height of the rim decides what you can cut in one press. A buttermilk biscuit rolled to three-quarters of an inch needs a cutter taller than that or the dough folds over the top edge instead of being cut, which seals the layers and costs you the rise. Ateco publishes 1 1/4 inchon the 5457 rounds. Almost no novelty cutter publishes a height at all, and most are closer to half an inch — fine for a rolled sugar cookie at an eighth of an inch, wrong for a biscuit.

3. Whether the sizes are a published ladder.A graduated set is worth several times a random assortment, because the useful answer to “this cutter is slightly too big” is the next one down. Ateco publishes its ranges, with the caveat below. Wilton publishes 1 to 3.75 inch on the snowflake set. Fox Run publishes nothing on its own listing, and we have attributed the approximate figures to the retailers they came from.

4. How it stores. Nesting sets that come with a tin stay a set. Loose cutters in a drawer get crushed, and a crushed cutter cuts a crushed shape forever. Three of the five picks here nest into a tin; it is a bigger quality-of-life feature than it sounds.

5. Shape complexity, which cuts both ways.Intricate cutters make better looking cookies and release worse. Needle-thin points tear on the way out, and fine interior detail disappears as the cookie spreads. The sweet spot is a recognizable silhouette with no feature narrower than about a quarter inch — which is roughly where the snowflake set sits.

The published figures we could not settle

Three of the five picks have a specification that is published two different ways, and since this page ranks on published figures, it should say which.

The Ateco 5457 plain round set's top diameter.One retailer lists the range as 0.75 to 4.38 inches, another as about 0.88 to 4.4 inches, a third as 7/8 to 4 2/5 inches. The upper figures are the same number rounded three ways; the lower ones genuinely differ by an eighth of an inch. We could not reach an August Thomsen spec sheet to settle it, so the entry says “approx. 7/8 to 4 3/8 in” rather than asserting a precise ladder.

The Ateco 5307 fluted set's top diameter. Several foodservice retailers publish 3/4 inch to 3 1/4 inch; others publish 0.75 to 3.5 inch for the same 11-piece set. That is a real quarter-inch disagreement on the largest cutter, which is the one you would buy the set for if you cut full-size scones. If the biggest cutter is the reason you are buying, the plain 5457 set publishes a larger top size by every reading.

The Wilton 101-piece's material and care.Wilton's own product page lists the 101-piece cookie cutter set as a plasticset. The Amazon listing title names the contents — alphabet, numbers, holiday — and no material. Wilton's care instruction is to wash in warm soapy water and dry thoroughly; several third-party listings for the same set call it dishwasher safe. We would follow Wilton, because a dishwasher's drying cycle is exactly how thin plastic cutters warp.

Rounds are the set that earns its space

This is the argument of the page, so it is worth making properly rather than asserting.

A graduated round set is the only cutter purchase that gets used outside of a holiday. Buttermilk biscuits and scones are cut rounds — and cut, not twisted; twisting seals the edge and the biscuit rises lopsided. Doughnuts are a large round and a small one. English muffins are rings. Tart and pie bases are rounds sized a half inch wider than the tin. Dumpling and empanada wrappers are rounds. Sandwich cookies need two matched rounds. Crumpets and savory galettes are rounds. A twelve-size ladder covers all of that, and the reason to own the ladder rather than two cutters is that a half inch either way changes how many you get out of a sheet of dough.

Shape sets are different. They are bought for an occasion, used for an evening, and stored for a year. That is not a criticism — decorated holiday cookies are one of the real pleasures of this hobby, and our piping bags and tips page is the other half of that purchase. It is an argument about order: buy the rounds first, then buy the shapes you have an actual plan for. The most common cutter-buying mistake is a hundred-piece assortment where four shapes get used and ninety-seven live in a pail.

The honest exception is letters and numbers. No metal set we found includes them, they cannot be improvised, and a name or an age on a tray of cookies is the whole point of the tray. That is why the Wilton 101-piece is ranked second despite being plastic with a conflicting care instruction: it does something nothing else here does.

Where cutters sit in the cookie workflow

Cut cookies and scooped cookies are two different recipes, which trips people up. A rolled, cut cookie needs a dough stiff enough to hold an edge and chilled enough not to spread — a sugar-cookie or shortbread dough. A soft drop dough cannot be cut at all, and that is what our cookie scoop roundup is for. If the dough is sticking to the cutter and tearing, the dough is too warm; if the shapes spread into blobs in the oven, the dough was too warm when it went in.

Roll on a lightly floured surface or between parchment with a rolling pin that gives you even thickness, cut as close together as you can manage, and bake on a flat, heavy sheet. A silicone mat is worth using here specifically because cut cookies are thin and a dark, thin sheet will color their bottoms before the tops set.

The short answer

Quick picks

#ProductBest forScorePrice
01
Ateco Ateco 5457 Plain Edge Round Cutters, 12-Piece
Ateco 5457 Plain Edge Round Cutters, 12-Piece

The cutter set that earns its drawer space every week rather than every December. Twelve graduated stainless rounds, published by retailers from roughly 7/8 inch to about 4 3/8 inch and 1 1/4 inch tall, nesting into one storage tin. Rounds are what you actually cut: biscuits, scones, dumpling wrappers, tart bases, doughnuts, English muffins and plain sugar cookies.

Most home bakers, year round
8.8
$34.87Amazon
02
Wilton Wilton Cookie Cutters Set, 101-Piece (Alphabet, Numbers and Holiday)
Wilton Cookie Cutters Set, 101-Piece (Alphabet, Numbers and Holiday)

A hundred and one cutters in a storage pail, including the full alphabet and numbers - which is the one thing no metal set gives you, and the reason a birthday or a name on a tray is suddenly possible. Note the material before you buy: Wilton's own catalog lists this set as PLASTIC, and the Amazon listing title does not say so.

Letters, numbers and sheer variety
7.4
$33.99Amazon
03
Ateco Ateco 5307 Fluted Edge Round Cutters, 11-Piece
Ateco 5307 Fluted Edge Round Cutters, 11-Piece

The same graduated stainless ladder as the plain set, with a crimped edge. That edge is not decoration: the flutes give a biscuit or scone more surface to climb on as it rises, and they hide the slight raggedness a plain cut leaves in a soft, high-fat dough.

Biscuits, scones and jam tarts
8.3
$29.89Amazon
04
Wilton Wilton Snowflake Metal Cookie Cutter Set, 7-Piece
Wilton Snowflake Metal Cookie Cutter Set, 7-Piece

Seven metal snowflake cutters published from 1 inch to 3.75 inches - a graduated set of one shape rather than one of each shape, which is the smarter way to buy a holiday cutter. A tray of snowflakes in seven sizes reads as decorated; a tray of seven unrelated shapes reads as whatever was in the drawer.

Christmas cookie trays
7.7
$10.99Amazon
05
Fox Run Fox Run Stainless Steel Star Cookie Cutters, Set of 5
Fox Run Stainless Steel Star Cookie Cutters, Set of 5

Five graduated stainless stars for pocket money. The budget pick, and a genuinely useful one: a star is the most used cutter shape after a round, it works for Christmas and for nothing in particular, and stainless means it survives being left wet.

The budget pick
7.8
$11.49Amazon

#ad · Live prices from the Amazon Product API, as of November 17, 2026. Where we have no verified live price we show none — a gap beats a number that has rotted.

In detail

The picks, in full

01
Ateco Ateco 5457 Plain Edge Round Cutters, 12-Piece

Most home bakers, year round

Ateco 5457 Plain Edge Round Cutters, 12-Piece

12 graduated roundsApprox. 7/8 to 4 3/8 in1 1/4 in cutting depthStainless steelNests in a storage tin
8.8/10

The cutter set that earns its drawer space every week rather than every December. Twelve graduated stainless rounds, published by retailers from roughly 7/8 inch to about 4 3/8 inch and 1 1/4 inch tall, nesting into one storage tin. Rounds are what you actually cut: biscuits, scones, dumpling wrappers, tart bases, doughnuts, English muffins and plain sugar cookies.

Cut quality
9
Size range
9.5
Published specs
7.5
Build & durability
9.5
Value
8.5

Pros

  • A full graduated ladder, so the cutter matches the recipe instead of the recipe matching the one cutter you own
  • 1 1/4 inch of cutting depth clears a thick biscuit in one press, where a shallow cutter has to be pushed through in stages
  • Stainless rather than tinplate, which is the single spec that decides whether a wet cutter left in the sink rusts

Cons

  • Retailer listings disagree on the top diameter - 4.38 in, 4.4 in and 4 2/5 in all appear, and we could not reach an Ateco spec sheet to settle it
  • No handles or grips, so pressing the smallest rings through chilled dough is hard on fingertips
  • Rounds only - this set makes no shapes, which is what a lot of people mean by cookie cutters

Don't buy this if…

…you want shapes for holiday cookies - this is a precision round set, and a shape set is a different purchase.

$34.87View on Amazon

Price as of November 17, 2026. Prices change — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to Ateco 5457 Plain Edge Round Cutters, 12-Piece

02
Wilton Wilton Cookie Cutters Set, 101-Piece (Alphabet, Numbers and Holiday)

Letters, numbers and sheer variety

Wilton Cookie Cutters Set, 101-Piece (Alphabet, Numbers and Holiday)

101 cuttersPlastic (per Wilton's catalog)Full alphabet and numbersStorage pail includedCare instructions conflict
7.4/10

A hundred and one cutters in a storage pail, including the full alphabet and numbers - which is the one thing no metal set gives you, and the reason a birthday or a name on a tray is suddenly possible. Note the material before you buy: Wilton's own catalog lists this set as PLASTIC, and the Amazon listing title does not say so.

Cut quality
6.5
Size range
9.5
Published specs
6
Build & durability
6
Value
9

Pros

  • The complete alphabet and number set, which metal cutter sets essentially never include
  • The variety is real - holiday, animal and theme shapes alongside the letters, in one pail
  • Plastic is lighter and kinder to small hands, which matters because this is the set children use

Cons

  • Plastic, not metal: Wilton's own product page lists the 101-piece as a plastic set while the Amazon listing title omits the material entirely
  • A plastic edge does not cut chilled stiff dough as cleanly as a stainless rim, and it cannot be sharpened or re-rounded
  • Care instructions conflict - Wilton publishes warm soapy water, hand washing, while some third-party listings call the set dishwasher safe

Don't buy this if…

…you cut firm chilled dough and want a crisp edge - a stainless set cuts better and lasts longer, it just cannot spell.

$33.99View on Amazon

Price as of November 17, 2026. Prices change — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to Wilton Cookie Cutters Set, 101-Piece (Alphabet, Numbers and Holiday)

03
Ateco Ateco 5307 Fluted Edge Round Cutters, 11-Piece

Biscuits, scones and jam tarts

Ateco 5307 Fluted Edge Round Cutters, 11-Piece

11 graduated fluted roundsPublished 3/4 to 3 1/4 inStainless steelNests in a storage tinTop size disputed by retailers
8.3/10

The same graduated stainless ladder as the plain set, with a crimped edge. That edge is not decoration: the flutes give a biscuit or scone more surface to climb on as it rises, and they hide the slight raggedness a plain cut leaves in a soft, high-fat dough.

Cut quality
8.5
Size range
8.5
Published specs
7
Build & durability
9.5
Value
8

Pros

  • A fluted edge is the traditional cut for scones and jam tarts, and it disguises a less-than-perfect press
  • Graduated sizing means the whole ladder from a canape base to a full scone
  • Same stainless construction and nesting tin as the plain Ateco set

Cons

  • Retailers publish two different top sizes for this set - 3 1/4 in at several and 3.5 in at others - so the largest cutter is not a settled figure
  • Flutes trap dough in the corrugations and need a brush rather than a rinse
  • A fluted edge is wrong for anything you want to stack or glaze flat, so this is a second set rather than a first one

Don't buy this if…

…you want one round set to do everything - buy the plain 12-piece, which cuts cleanly for every use including the ones flutes suit.

$29.89View on Amazon

Price as of November 17, 2026. Prices change — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to Ateco 5307 Fluted Edge Round Cutters, 11-Piece

04
Wilton Wilton Snowflake Metal Cookie Cutter Set, 7-Piece

Christmas cookie trays

Wilton Snowflake Metal Cookie Cutter Set, 7-Piece

7 snowflake cuttersPublished 1 to 3.75 inMetal, color coatedGraduated one-shape setNo steel grade published
7.7/10

Seven metal snowflake cutters published from 1 inch to 3.75 inches - a graduated set of one shape rather than one of each shape, which is the smarter way to buy a holiday cutter. A tray of snowflakes in seven sizes reads as decorated; a tray of seven unrelated shapes reads as whatever was in the drawer.

Cut quality
8
Size range
8
Published specs
7
Build & durability
7
Value
8.5

Pros

  • Publishes its size range, which most novelty cutter sets do not - 1 in to 3.75 in is the useful spread
  • Graduated sizes of a single shape is what makes a decorated tray look composed
  • Intricate enough to be worth the detail, simple enough that the dough releases - snowflake points are the usual failure and these are not needle-thin

Cons

  • Color-coated metal, and Wilton publishes no steel grade or coating detail, so corrosion resistance is unknown
  • Deeply fluted shapes need chilled dough and a flour dip or the points tear - a technique requirement, not a defect
  • One shape, one season - this sits in a box for eleven months

Don't buy this if…

…you want cutters for year-round baking - a graduated round set does more work in a month than this does in a year.

$10.99View on Amazon

Price as of November 17, 2026. Prices change — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to Wilton Snowflake Metal Cookie Cutter Set, 7-Piece

05
Fox Run Fox Run Stainless Steel Star Cookie Cutters, Set of 5

The budget pick

Fox Run Stainless Steel Star Cookie Cutters, Set of 5

5 graduated starsStainless steelRetailers list approx. 2 to 3.5 inStorage tin per retailersSizes not on the Amazon listing
7.8/10

Five graduated stainless stars for pocket money. The budget pick, and a genuinely useful one: a star is the most used cutter shape after a round, it works for Christmas and for nothing in particular, and stainless means it survives being left wet.

Cut quality
8
Size range
7
Published specs
6
Build & durability
8.5
Value
9.5

Pros

  • Stainless at a price where most cutters are tinplate or plastic
  • Graduated sizes of one shape, which is the pattern that makes a tray look intentional
  • A star is a year-round shape, unlike most novelty cutters

Cons

  • Fox Run's Amazon listing publishes neither the diameters nor the tin - the roughly 2 in to 3.5 in range here comes from two other retailers' listings for the same set
  • Listings for Fox Run star sets vary between five and six pieces with different ranges, so check the count on arrival
  • Five points mean five places for dough to stick - these need a flour dip more than a round does

Don't buy this if…

…you need a precise published size - buy the Ateco rounds, which are the only cutters here with a documented ladder and depth.

$11.49View on Amazon

Price as of November 17, 2026. Prices change — Amazon's at checkout is the one that counts.

#ad · we may earn a commission from this link to Fox Run Stainless Steel Star Cookie Cutters, Set of 5

How to choose and use cookie cutters

Buy one graduated stainless round set, then shapes with a plan

If you are buying once, buy the rounds. If you are buying for a holiday, buy a graduated set of oneshape rather than one of each — it is the difference between a tray that looks composed and a tray that looks like a drawer. Buy stainless whenever the listing names the metal, and treat an unnamed metal as tinplate until proven otherwise.

Chill the dough, then chill it again

Nearly every cutter problem is a temperature problem. Dough at room temperature sticks to the cutter, tears on release and spreads in the oven, and no cutter fixes any of that. Roll, cut, then chill the cut shapes on the sheet for fifteen minutes before they go in the oven; that second chill is what keeps a snowflake's points sharp through the bake.

Press straight down, and never twist

Press firmly straight down until you feel the board, then lift straight up. Twisting is the habit to break: on a laminated or biscuit dough it seals the cut edge and the layers cannot open, which is the real reason home biscuits come out shorter than they should.

Dip in flour for intricate shapes, not for rounds

A light dip of the cutting edge in flour between presses stops sticking on detailed shapes — stars, snowflakes, anything with a point. Rounds generally do not need it, and extra flour on a sugar cookie shows as a pale dusty surface after baking. Tap the excess off.

Cut from the outside in, and re-roll scraps only once

Start at the edge of the sheet of dough and work inward, cutting as close together as possible — every gap is a scrap. Re-rolled scraps are tougher because of the extra working, so gather them once, chill, roll and cut, and accept that the second batch bakes a little firmer. A bench scraper is the tool for lifting cut shapes without stretching them.

Dry them immediately, and store them nested

Dry every cutter fully before it goes away, even stainless ones, and particularly any cutter whose metal is not named on the listing. Tinplate rust starts at a scratch in the coating and goes straight through. Store nesting sets in their tin and loose cutters in a rigid box — a cutter that has been crushed under a cast iron pan cuts a crushed shape for the rest of its life, and you cannot press a shape back to true the way you can a plain round.

What we did not feature, and why

The large unbranded shape assortments— 18, 24 and 30-piece stainless sets of mixed shapes — which dominate search results here. Several are probably fine, and some publish 18/8 stainless, which is genuinely good. We left them off because none we checked published a size ladder or a cutting depth, the brands have no continuity so a replacement is not orderable, and “30 mini shapes” is a variety claim rather than a specification. If you buy one, buy the one that names its steel grade.

Plunger and stamp cutters (spring-loaded cutters that eject a fondant or cookie shape with an embossed pattern). A real category and a different purchase, aimed at fondant work rather than dough.

3D-printed custom cutters.Available in any shape imaginable, and the material question is unresolved enough — layer lines are hard to clean and most filaments are not rated for repeated hot washing — that we are not ranking one as a primary cutter.

The Wilton Holiday Metal Cutter Set of 3, which is live and cheap. Three cutters is not a set in the sense this page means, and the graduated snowflake set does the same job better for a couple of dollars more.

How we picked

We don't run a testing lab

We read the manuals, compiled the published specifications, did the wattage-to-dough math and weighed aggregated owner reviews, then scored each product against a published rubric. The scores are judgments from documented research — they are not measurements we took, because we do not have a lab and we're not going to pretend we do. Every spec is the manufacturer's published figure, cited in Sources.

Questions

Frequently asked

Are the Wilton 101-piece cookie cutters metal or plastic?
Plastic. Wilton's own product page lists the 101-piece cookie cutter set as a plastic set, and the Amazon listing title names the contents — alphabet, numbers and holiday shapes — without stating the material. That is worth knowing before you buy: plastic cannot be sharpened or pressed back into shape, and a plastic edge does not cut firm chilled dough as crisply as a stainless rim. It is still the pick we rank second, because no metal set we found includes a full alphabet and numbers, and that is what most people are buying this for. Follow Wilton's care instruction — warm soapy water, dried thoroughly — rather than the third-party listings that call the set dishwasher safe.
What size cookie cutter should I use for biscuits?
Between 2 and 2 1/2 inches for a standard buttermilk biscuit, and the cutter needs to be taller than the dough is thick. That is the specification most novelty cutters fail: a biscuit rolled to 3/4 inch needs a cutter with more than 3/4 inch of rim, or the dough folds over the top edge rather than being cut through. Ateco publishes 1 1/4 inch of depth on its plain round set, which clears any biscuit. Cut straight down and lift straight up - twisting seals the cut edge and the layers cannot rise.
Stainless steel or tinplate cookie cutters?
Stainless, if the listing names the metal. Tinplate is steel with a thin tin coating, and the moment that coating is scratched or the cutter is put away damp, the steel underneath rusts - on the surface that touches food. It is why inexpensive vintage-style cutters so often have orange speckles. Stainless can be washed hot, left wet, and pressed back toward round. The practical rule: if a listing says only "metal", assume tinplate and dry it immediately.
Why does the dough stick to my cookie cutters?
The dough is too warm. Chilled dough releases cleanly from a bare cutter; room-temperature dough sticks regardless of what the cutter is made of. Chill the rolled sheet until it is firm before cutting, work in batches so the rest stays cold, and dip the cutting edge in flour between presses for intricate shapes - tapping the excess off, because flour left on a sugar cookie bakes to a pale dusty patch. If the shapes still tear on release, the dough is either too warm or too wet.
How do you keep cut cookies from spreading and losing their shape?
Chill the cut shapes on the baking sheet for about fifteen minutes before they go in the oven. That second chill, after cutting rather than before, is the step that keeps a snowflake's points sharp and a star's angles crisp - the fat in the dough has to be solid when it hits the oven heat. Baking on a light, heavy, flat sheet helps too, because a thin dark sheet colors the thin bottoms of cut cookies before the tops have set.
Can cookie cutters go in the dishwasher?
Stainless cutters survive it; plastic and tinplate should not go in. A dishwasher's heated drying cycle is the usual way thin plastic cutters warp out of shape, and it drives water into the seams of tinplate where the rust starts. Wilton publishes warm soapy water and thorough drying for its plastic 101-piece set, which conflicts with some third-party listings calling it dishwasher safe - follow the manufacturer. Whatever the metal, dry every cutter fully before storing it, because a closed box is where corrosion happens.

Keep reading

More in this category

More baking gear

All baking gear →

Receipts

Sources

We don't run a testing lab, and we don't pretend to. Specs are the manufacturer's published figures, cited above; scores are our judgments from that research. Where we couldn't verify something, we say so on the page rather than quietly leaving it out. Read our full method.